Welcome to leisuretimecigars Store!
Oct 30, 2026 / By Salvatore Buttafuoco / in Cigar Guides
Alec Bradley and My Father are both family names in the premium cigar world, but the families built very different cigars. Alec Bradley, founded by Alan Rubin and now joined by his sons Alec and Bradley, leans on Honduran tobacco and outside blending partnerships to produce polished, medium-bodied smokes. My Father is the Garcia family's Nicaraguan operation — Cuban-trained rollers, estate-grown Nicaraguan tobacco, and blends that carry a distinctive peppery signature.
If you are choosing between them, the deciding factor is usually character rather than quality. Alec Bradley tends to be the smoother, woodier, more easygoing smoke. My Father tends to be the bolder, spicier, more structured one. This comparison walks through what each brand actually sells at Leisure Time Cigars, how the key lines differ in wrapper, strength and format, and the smartest way to try both.
Alec Bradley built its name on Honduran tobacco and on lines like Black Market, introduced in 2011, that pair a dark Nicaraguan wrapper from the Jalapa Valley with Honduran and Panamanian fillers. The brand's range in this catalog runs from medium up to medium-full, and its house style favors balance: rich flavors, delivered smoothly rather than aggressively.
The second generation is now part of the story. Alec and Bradley Rubin, the sons the brand is named for, created the Gatekeeper line with veteran blender E.P. Carrillo — a deliberate step out of their father's shadow, and a sign of where the brand is heading: the same Honduran heartland, blended with a lighter, more modern touch.
My Father is the Garcia family's brand, rooted in tobacco cultivation that goes back to pre-revolution Cuba and produced today at the family's factory in Esteli, Nicaragua. Where Alec Bradley blends across countries, My Father's stocked lines here are Nicaraguan puros in spirit: Nicaraguan binder and filler, much of it grown on Garcia estates, under Nicaraguan or Maduro wrappers.
The flagship here is Flor de las Antillas — "the flower of the Antilles," named for Cuba — the brand's debut box-pressed line. It shows the Garcia style at its most balanced: medium to full, with the family's trademark pepper woven through cocoa, sweet cedar and earth rather than dominating them.
The Gatekeeper Robusto is the modern Alec Bradley statement: 5 x 50 and rated medium strength, made by Tabacalera La Alianza with an Ecuadorian Habano wrapper over a Nicaraguan binder and Dominican and Nicaraguan fillers. Its product page describes a smooth succession of rich woody, nutty and leathery notes over a slow burn, and rates it approachable for newer smokers. At roughly 45 to 75 minutes, it is also the shortest commitment in this comparison.
Kintsugi is the Honduran expression of the brand: handcrafted at the Raices Cubanas factory in Danli, Honduras, with a Habano wrapper from the Trojes region over Honduran and Nicaraguan binder and filler, rated medium strength. It comes in four sizes — Corona Gorda (5-5/8 x 46), Robusto (5 x 50), Toro (6 x 52) and Gordo (6 x 60) — so the same blend can be tried as a focused corona or a long, cool-burning gordo.
The Black Market Churchill is the fuller end of Alec Bradley here: 7 x 50, rated medium to full, built in Honduras with a dark Nicaraguan wrapper from the Jalapa Valley, an Ecuadorian binder, and Honduran and Panamanian fillers. Its product page describes cocoa, coffee and a hint of hay up front, deepening into pronounced espresso and coffee through the second third. At 90 minutes to two hours, its own FAQ is blunt that it suits experienced smokers better than beginners.
Flor de las Antillas is My Father's counterpoint to the Black Market: also medium to full, but a Nicaraguan puro — sun-grown Nicaraguan wrapper over Nicaraguan binder and filler — and box-pressed, which changes both the feel in hand and the draw. It comes in four box-pressed vitolas: Belicoso (5-1/2 x 52), DeSocio (5-3/4 x 54), Toro (6 x 52) and Toro Grande (6 x 60), smoking from about an hour to an hour and a half. The flavor profile its FAQ describes — cocoa, pepper, sweet cedar and earth — is the Garcia signature in its friendliest form.
The Maduro version takes the same concept darker: a dark Maduro wrapper over Nicaraguan binder and long filler aged on Garcia estates, produced at the My Father factory in Esteli. Rated medium to full, it trades the original's sweet cedar for chocolate, wood, espresso, earth and roasted nuts, with a distinctive peppery spice its page aims at seasoned palates. Its four vitolas start smaller — Petit Robusto (4-1/2 x 50) and Corona (5-5/8 x 46) — which makes it the more forgiving way into the line.
The flavors differ as much as the strength. Alec Bradley leans woody, nutty and leathery with cocoa and coffee in the Black Market. My Father leans cocoa and cedar with a pepper note that runs through both Flor de las Antillas lines — milder in the original, more pronounced in the Maduro.
For a newer smoker, the Gatekeeper Robusto is the safest door in on this page. For an experienced smoker who wants the richest smoke here, it is the Flor de las Antillas Maduro in the Toro Gordo, or the Black Market Churchill if the evening allows two hours.
My Father makes the first step easy with its 5 Cigar Sampler, the low-commitment way to learn the Garcia style before choosing between the two Flor de las Antillas lines. Alec Bradley has no sampler in the current catalog, so the practical route there is to start with a single line at the strength you prefer — the medium Gatekeeper Robusto or Kintsugi Robusto first, and the Black Market Churchill once you know you like the house style.
That order — sampler or single line first, opinions second, boxes last — keeps the comparison honest without a large upfront spend on either side.
Q: Is Alec Bradley or My Father stronger?
A: My Father, in the lines stocked here. Both Flor de las Antillas lines are rated medium to full, while Alec Bradley's Gatekeeper and Kintsugi are rated medium and only the Black Market Churchill reaches medium-full.
Q: What is the main flavor difference between Alec Bradley and My Father?
A: Alec Bradley leans woody, nutty and leathery, with cocoa, coffee and espresso in the Black Market Churchill. My Father leans cocoa, cedar and earth with a characteristic pepper note, which is softest in the original Flor de las Antillas and boldest in the Maduro.
Q: I am newer to cigars. Which one should I try first?
A: Start with the Alec & Bradley Gatekeeper Robusto — medium strength, a classic 5 x 50 size, and a profile its product page rates approachable for newer smokers. From My Father, the original Flor de las Antillas in the Belicoso is the gentler introduction; save the Maduro for later.
Q: Do Alec Bradley and My Father sell samplers?
A: My Father offers a 5 Cigar Sampler in the current catalog. Alec Bradley does not list a sampler here at the moment, so start with one line — Gatekeeper or Kintsugi in Robusto size is the natural first step.
Start with the Alec & Bradley Gatekeeper Robusto for the smooth medium-bodied take, or the My Father Flor de las Antillas for the box-pressed Nicaraguan one — compare them against the Alec Bradley Black Market Churchill and the Flor de las Antillas Maduro, and let your own palate settle Alec Bradley vs My Father.
Oct 25, 2026 by Salvatore Buttafuoco
Oct 14, 2026 by Salvatore Buttafuoco
